Monday, July 12, 2010

Business owners: Documenting the use of a vehicle to comply with CRA's requirement

This posting explains the ways in which a person who uses a vehicle in a business can keep track of business travel.

When a vehicle is used partially for business purposes and partially for other purposes, the expenses relating to its use must be apportioned. Only those expenses relating to the business travel or commercial activity are considered eligible for a business deduction and for input tax credits on GST/HST. The proration in such cases is done based on the distances driven. To support a deduction or claim, the person must know and be able to demonstrate the distance travelled for business purposes and commercial activities.

The Income Tax Act and the Excise Tax Act do not set out specific documentary requirements for recording the usage of a vehicle. The general rule is that the person must retain records that would enable an objective determination of the person's tax payable.

Full logbook
The best evidence to support the use of a vehicle is an accurate logbook of business travel maintained for the entire year, showing for each business trip, the destination, the reason for the trip and the distance covered.

Alternative records
The fact that a viable business exists is usually a strong indicator that a person incurred vehicle expenses, because it is extremely difficult to carry on a business without doing at least some driving. Claims for a very low amount of business use do not require extensive records to demonstrate business travel. As the percentage of business use and the related expense claims increase, more documentation, as discussed below, is expected to be available.

For many persons, the books and records they already retain as part of their normal business operations may be indicative of the presence of and the extent of business driving. An appointment diary indicating what addresses were visited and why, or a log of service calls might be sufficient. Purchase or sales invoices may indicate that items were picked up or delivered by the taxpayer. Examples of other evidence that may be taken into consideration may include:

•whether the person has another vehicle for personal travel,
•the type of vehicle,
•the nature of the business and the business travel likely required,
•who else drives the vehicle (e.g., family),
•how the vehicle is insured, and
•indications of other personal travel.

CRA auditors will generally consider the usage of a vehicle in the context of the entire operation of that particular business. A proposal to disallow a portion of a claim for vehicle expenses would only occur where the claimed travel seems out of proportion in that overall context and is not supported by sufficient evidence as described here. However, it should be noted that individuals will be responsible for providing sufficient evidence to demonstrate the accuracy of their claims for business distances driven throughout the year.

Logbook for a sample period
The CRA would be prepared to afford considerable weight to a logbook maintained for a sample period as evidence of a full year's usage of a vehicle if it meets the following criteria.

•The taxpayer has previously filled out and retained a logbook covering a full 12-month period that was typical for the business (the “base year”). The 12-month period is not required to be a calendar year.
•A logbook for a sample period of at least one continuous three-month period in each subsequent year has been maintained (the “sample year period”).
•The distances travelled and the business use of the vehicle during the three-month sample period is within 10 percentage points of the corresponding figures for the same three-month period in the base year (the “base year period”).
•The calculated annual business use of the vehicle in a subsequent year does not go up or down by more than 10 percentage points in comparison to the base year.
The business use of the vehicle in the subsequent year will be calculated by multiplying the business use as determined in the base year by the ratio of the sample period and base year period. The formula for this calculation is as follows:

(Sample year period % ÷ Base year period %) × Base year annual % = Calculated annual business use

Where the calculated annual business use in a later year goes up or down by more than 10%, the base year is not an appropriate indicator of annual usage in that later year. In such a case, the sample period logbook would only be reliable for the three-month period it had been maintained. For the remainder of the year, the business use of the vehicle would need to be determined based on an actual record of travel or alternative records, as discussed above. In these circumstances, the taxpayer should consider establishing a new base year by maintaining a logbook for a new 12-month period.

Example:

An individual has completed a logbook for a full 12-month period, which showed a business use percentage in each quarter of 52/46/39/67 and an annual business use of the vehicle as 49%. In a subsequent year, a logbook was maintained for a three-month sample period during April, May and June, which showed the business use as 51%. In the base year, the percentage of business use of the vehicle for the months April, May and June was 46%. The business use of the vehicle would be calculated as follows:

(51% ÷ 46%) × 49% = 54%

In this case, the CRA would accept, in the absence of contradictory evidence, the calculated annual business use of the vehicle for the subsequent year as 54%. (I.e., the calculated annual business use is within 10% of the annual business use in the base year – it is not lower than 39% or higher than 59%.)

Even though records and supporting documents are only required to be kept for a period of six years from the end of the tax year to which they relate, the logbook for the full 12-month period must be kept for a period of six years from the end of the tax year for which it is last used to establish business use.

Wednesday, July 7, 2010

Business owners: Why you should have an HOLDING Company...

Today, I would like to share a great article written by Tim Cestnick. Tim is managing director at WaterStreet Family Wealth Counsel and author of 101 Tax Secrets for Canadians.

HOLDING COMPANY

This summer when you're standing around the barbecue with your business-owner neighbours, impress them with your knowledge of tax planning.

I can tell you from experience that you'll bore them to tears with the conversation, but they'll thank you later when the tax savings start rolling in. Specifically, share with them that holding companies can help them to defer tax. Here are the highlights.

THE RULES

If you happen to own a corporation that carries on an active business, give some thought to setting up your affairs to allow for a deferral of tax.

How? By establishing a holding company to own the shares of your active business corporation (ABC).

You see, if you own the shares of your ABC directly, then any payment of dividends from that corporation to you will be taxable in your hands personally in the year you receive those dividends.

If, on the other hand, you have a personal holding company that owns your shares in your ABC, you can pay a dividend to your holding company that will, in most cases, be tax free to your holding company.

It's subsection 112(1) of our tax law that allows, in most cases, your holding company to claim a deduction for taxable dividends received from your ABC. And, as long as your holding company and ABC are "connected" under our tax law (which will be the case in the vast majority of situations), you'll avoid another tax called the Part Four tax.

By passing some of those earnings from your ABC to your holding company, you'll defer tax, which is essentially the difference between the tax paid by your ABC on its profits, and the amount of tax you would have paid had the profits been paid out immediately to you as a bonus.

The tax deferred is approximately 30 per cent of the taxable income in most provinces for someone in the highest tax bracket.

THE STRATEGIES

What strategies should you be thinking about?

Multiple shareholders: If you're one of multiple shareholders in your ABC, setting up a personal holding company for each shareholder can provide flexibility to each of you.

Think of each holding company as a tap to control the payment of dividends to each of you personally.

Your ABC can pay dividends to each of the holding companies on a tax-free basis, and then each holding company can pay dividends to its shareholders based on his or her personal cash requirements.

Splitting income: Your holding company can be owned by more than one person in the family.

Your spouse, for example, could own some shares. This will allow you to sprinkle dividends to your spouse or others in the family so that the tax burden on those dividends can be shared.

It's not always advisable to issue shares in the holding company directly to your children (and if they're minors, this isn't possible), and so a family trust can be utilized, which brings me to the next strategy.

Establish a trust: I really like this structure. The shares of your ABC can be held by a family trust.

The beneficiaries of the trust will include you, your spouse, your children (regardless of their age), and your holding company.

Now, any dividends paid by your ABC to the trust can be distributed out to your holding company as a beneficiary of the trust, and you'll achieve the same tax-free payment to the holding company as you would achieve if the holding company owned the shares in the ABC directly, provided the two companies are "connected."

The advantages, however, include: The ability to sprinkle dividends to family members or the holding company as beneficiaries of the trust, at your discretion; the ability to multiply the lifetime capital gains exemption on a sale of the shares of your ABC (assuming the shares qualify for the exemption); creditor protection over the property of the trust, including the shares of the ABC, among other benefits.

Protection from creditors: Any excess profits of your ABC can be paid to your holding company as dividends, and can be lent back to your operating business on a secured basis, if the cash is needed for the business. This will protect those excess profits from other creditors of the business.

Retirement nest egg: The accumulation of assets inside your holding company can become the type of retirement nest egg or "pension" that you will need to look after yourself during retirement.

As usual, please do not hesitate to contact me to discuss the above.